Peer Reviews and Graduate Writers: Engagements with Language and Disciplinary Differences While Responding to Writing

Main Article Content

Kate Mangelsdorf Todd Ruecker

Abstract

Although peer review as a method of writing response has been examined extensively, only limited research exists on peer review at the graduate level. This study examines graduate students’ peer review interactions in a writing workshop in which first- and second-language students from different disciplines were enrolled.  The researchers focused on how students engaged with language and disciplinary differences as they peer reviewed.   Data were collected from two separate writing workshop classes over two semesters and included videorecordings, observation notes, writing samples, and end of semester surveys.  The researchers found that some students could provide only limited assistance when working with peers from different fields.  The peer review groups’ effectiveness was strained when there were large gaps in academic levels.  However, peer review groups were generally productive when students from different language backgrounds worked together.  The peer reviews were effective in raising students’ rhetorical awareness and strengthening their understanding of genre conventions.  Students showed an openness to language differences, and in their discussions they helped each other navigate the challenges of graduate school. Implications for using peer review in writing interventions for graduate students are discussed. 

 

Article Details

How to Cite
Mangelsdorf, K., & Ruecker, T. (2018). Peer Reviews and Graduate Writers: Engagements with Language and Disciplinary Differences While Responding to Writing. Journal of Response to Writing, 4(1). Retrieved from http://journalrw.org/index.php/jrw/article/view/98
Section
Featured Articles
Author Biographies

Kate Mangelsdorf, University of Texas at El Paso

Professor, Rhetoric and Writing Studies

English Department

Todd Ruecker, University of New Mexico

Assistant Professor, English Department