Critical Discourse Analysis of Student Responses to Teacher Feedback on Student Writing

Hee-Seung Kang, Julie Dykema

Abstract


This study explores the genre of ‘student response to teacher feedback’ and analyzes students’ responses through the framework of critical discourse analysis (CDA). Drawing on CDA as a theoretical framework, we examined the structural, interactional, and interdiscursive features of the students’ comments and investigated relations between the text, interaction, and context. The structural analysis indicates that the students’ comments demonstrate their emerging academic literacy skills. Our interactional analysis shows that most students took on an active role as a good student and a hard-working writer, but some students exerted their agency by taking an opportunity to resist the authority of the teacher while others rejected it altogether. Our interdiscursive analysis illustrates that students used not only language from the teacher’s comments, but also metalanguage of the composition classroom to formulate their responses. Based on our findings, we discuss implications for teaching practices and future research on students’ responses to teacher feedback. 


Keywords


critical discourse analysis; feedback; student response; teacher-written commentary; academic literacy; first-year composition

Full Text:

PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.




Co-Editors-in-Chief:

 

Grant Eckstein

Betsy Gilliland

(Brigham Young University)

(University of Hawai'i)

   
Editorial Board:Dana Ferris(University of California, Davis)
 John Bitchner(Auckland University of Technology)
 Norman Evans(Brigham Young University)
 Lynn Goldstein(Monterey Institute of International Studies)
 James Hartshorn(Brigham Young University)
 Fiona Hyland(The University of Hong Kong)
 Kendon Kurzer(University of California, Davis)
 Icy Lee(The Chinese University of Hong Kong)
 Karen Lunsford(University of California, Santa Barbara)